It was a perplexing first half of 2023. Wall Street was caught offside at what unfolded in the markets and this has led to growing uncertainty about the optimum strategy for the rest of the year.
At the beginning of the year, we remember, the dominant outlook was for a looming global recession. At this time, bonds were the favored asset class by strategists. Projections for equities were universally muted. It was anticipated the Fed would soon be able to stop and even reverse the rate hikes that did so much damage, last year.
Instead, the bearish outlook proved ill-advised. The NASDAQ (31.5%) and the S&P 500 (15.9%) scurried to nearly record first-half moves. Bonds fizzled as interest rates rose. The economy absorbed the pressure from further Fed rate hikes and a short-lived banking crisis. Meanwhile, the Fed continues on its course to push rates higher.
Markets defied conventional wisdom. As a result, broad disagreement swirls about the looming uncertainty for the months ahead. Forecasts for equities vary widely for the rest of 2023; from a gain of 10% by the most bullish strategist, to a decline of 27% from the most dour one.
From its current perch, the S&P 500 has now surged 20% above its low point, last October, and is now only 7% below its 2021 all-time high. This strong recovery is a relief for investors but it is probably time to expect a breather in this third quarter.
The predominant portion of the stock market gains were supported by the “Magnificent 7”, which comprise 36% of the total value of all of the stocks in the S&P 500. These stocks staged vigorous recoveries from their steep declines, last year.
2023 |
2022 |
|
Nvidia |
190% |
-54% |
Meta |
138% |
-67% |
Tesla |
113% |
-62% |
Amazon |
55% |
-50% |
Apple |
50% |
-55% |
The heady returns in a short period from such giant companies are far from normal in terms of investing. The axiom, the “higher they go, the further they fall”, can’t be ignored.
In other respects, stock market bulls were more restrained as the Russell 2000 has only gained 6% in 2023, while the DOW is almost unchanged.
Furthermore, it is worth considering that most of the gains in the S&P 500 occurred in the two bookend months of January and June (13%). During the other months, the market barely gained.
Largely supported by the burst in the month of June, stocks have now gained three quarters in a row. It stands to reason that prices should soften in the months ahead. At best, there could be rotation within the stock market where some of the areas that have been left behind, play catch up with the mega-cap tech stocks. Last year’s leaders like Lockheed Martin (-4%), Merck (-4%) General Mills (-8% ), and United Healthcare (-12%) might offer examples.
Unlike the outset of the second quarter, there is good reason to be cautious and take something off the table from the winners.
First of all, historically, stocks weaken following such a large first-half advance. Of the 15 largest gains in the first half, the market slips in the second half more than one-half the time, and in almost every case, momentum slows.
Secondly, TINA no longer applies. Simply said, there is an alternative to stocks. Cash now pays 5% and is trending higher. People can now earn a solid return on their money without taking any risks. This, almost certainly, will be a strong headwind for the market in the months ahead.
With stocks at elevated levels, rising interest rates, continued inflation pressures, and the beckoning call of a “sure thing”, we are at a decidedly different juncture than we were at the beginning of Q2.
Dan Botti
Investment Manager
7/15/2023
Click to Download the Market Overview PDF
Past Performance is no guarantee of future results. Investment management involves the possibility of losses. The significant general stock market moves up and down can influence the performance of client portfolios. Client holdings can vary. Any security identified and described does not represent all securities purchased, sold, or recommended for client accounts. The reader should not assume that an investment in the securities identified was or will be profitable.
Peregrine Asset Advisers ● 9755 SW Barnes Rd. Suite 295 ● Portland Oregon 97225
503.459.4651 ● 800.278.1420 ● www.peregrineaa.com